Sunday, September 20, 2009

EXPANDED OFFICE HOURS

Hello, everyone!

It was great to see some of ya'll at the help session this afternoon.

As promised I'm posting expanded office hours for this week both to make up for the holiday on Monday (when my hours normally are 1-3) and also to make sure I'm as available as possible to help on your designs due Thursday.

Tuesday: 10am-12:30pm (right before class); 2-6pm (after)
Wednesday: 1-2pm

If none of these work with your schedule, e-mail me! I have other availabilities for appointments and we can certainly work something out. Hope you have a great holiday tomorrow - if you're around Newhouse, check out the public diplomacy panel at 2pm featuring David Pogue (NYT tech editor) and Marjane Satrapi (of Persepolis fame). This isn't for extra credit, but it looks like an awesome panel.

Saturday, September 19, 2009

Badly Used Type

Besides the fact that there is way too much going on within this advertisement. The many different uses of text, frankly bad use of text, and the total abomination of an image concretely makes this ad an ineffective one. My eye has no starting point or ending point besides the date header at the top. After that, it's all up for grabs.

Specifically commenting on badly used type, the designer should have used the same sans serif font from the date header in the type of the band's name or rather even use the serif font in the header and the sans as the band's name. To me, everything is competing in this ad for "visual time" with my eye and as a whole it lost the battle...I'm moving on.

The Text of Text.


"A stable body of ideas expressed in essential form" is what Lupton describes the final product of "text" as. Staying on track with my vintage advertisements, I would like to point out that this one in particular has horrid placing of text. None of it is pointing to the product being sold and the different blocks on text are scattered throughout without any clear reason to why they are placed there. The kerning seems OK in this, except for the bottom paragraph is very hard to read because the text is so small and the x-height combined with the particular font chosen does not make it easy on the eyes!

None of the fonts used are in consistent either- and the script in the upper right corner along with the tiny block print in the bottom left is so hard to read that this ad serves more like an article (a piece that you have to spend time reading through in order to really get the message). Clearly, the graphics and design did not do a very good job on catching our attention, therefore even if it was an article, I don't think many of us would spend time going through it! All in all, this fails and could only be fixed by choosing about two different font families- less words, bigger message- and playing with both the font and graphics to get the reader or onlooker interested in the article.

Yekaterina Grishchenko

Effective Type in Advertisement: Garnier

While perusing the Daily Orange online, I saw the Garnier ad embedded below.


The designer(s) of this ad have constructed an effective ad not only with visuals, but more importantly with the text. Lupton writes that the viewer need hierarchy in their viewing, a way to follow along through the layout, book, etc. At first glance, I am imediately drawn to the 'HOLD' in the ad. The use of a sans serif font with a color pulled from the shampoo bottle gives the advertisement fluidity and most importantly conveys that the products will 'HOLD'. In addition, I appreciate the designer's choice of selecting a left justify. In a way I think the left justification helps to lead me to the product. I know the woman's eye-line accomplishes that task, but I believe the choice of left justification only strengthens that aspect.

Friday, September 18, 2009

Alignment Issues with Cowboys & Indians Layout

Throughout Lupton's chapter, "Text," she writes about typography and its use. One major component of using typography well with design is alignment. Tonight I was still searching for that one example of poor use and I opened the Cowboys & Indians magazine my grandparents had in their living room in Texas (you probably wouldn't find this magazine in New York).


(Although I am a photographer, this is just a camera phone snap - forgive me.)

C&I, I think, tried to be creative with their justification and alignment, but they failed. There needs to be some consistency with the paragraphs of type and there is none. At first glance you think they are going from right justification to left justification and back again continuing that sequence, but they are not. Their header for the top paragraph is inconsistent with the way the other headers are in relation to the ones that are right justified.

This could have been improved if the designer would have stayed with a more consistent use for the type so the user would be aware of the redundancy allowing him or her to follow along easier.

Hierarchy- Jen Brotman


I think this advertisement in Ms. Magazine is very effective. The bold, sans serif headline is very effective because of the alignment and leading. The center alignment creates a hierarchy within the headline, but also with the headline as a unit of type. It creates almost an arrow to the last line which says "really sucks." The "really sucks" then ties into the image, which also directs the reader to the word sucks. The headline is also leaded so that it remains a strong unit by not being too far apart. The alignment and leading really convey the message of the advertisement. The subhead, which is then in a smaller, serif font, gets the reader involved by providing a call to action. It also fits within the hierarchy because, while it is still center aligned like the headline, it is in a smaller font.

Nike's spacing issues






One of the main points that Lupton weaves throughout her chapter, "Text," is the importance of spacing in typography and design. Spacing is key in making any advertisement readably and esthetically pleasing to the eye. I think Nike missed the spacing mark on this one. I feel as though the space had so much potential and Nike just killed it by adding purple dashes and lines to frame the text on the page. The spacing and placing of the text is horrible. When trying to decipher the ad, I found myself tilting my head from left to right and squinting just to figure out what was on the page. The design and the typography are infused only in the fact that the same color scheme was vaguely used and reiterated . Although the hierarchy of the ad works well because the framing of the text by the bright colors draws me right to the type, the odd slanting and placement of the type within the inadequately used space does nothing but work against the success of the ad.

Nair Ad- Stacie Foster

I like this ad for Nair hair removal because the image used draws the readers attention to the text. The women's leg leads directly to the meat of the advertisement, which details the glory of the product. The ad also uses warm colors, like orange and pink that once again bring the readers' eye in. I also like the typeface used for the product logo. I think it is feminine, which is reflective of the product. The typeface used underneath the logo that "pretty" is written in, is a novelty font used correctly. The curve of the "y" in pretty leads the eye down to the statement "large wax strips." Overall I think this was a very effective ad.

Fit Finds


This ad for Nike is appealing in the way the alignment of text curves mimics that of the woman's curves in the image to the left. The text of the poem is light with a larger leading while "MY BUTT" and "Just Do It" are brighter and more bold, creating a visual hierarchy. The Nike logo is placed in the lower left hand corner as an exit point for the reader when scanning the page.
The ad for Reebok below is also a good example of hierarchy in that it uses the bright red to draw attention to the punching bag in contrast to the grayish background. The woman is kicking in the direction that points to the Reebok logo, and the spatial arrangement- with the graphic in the middle set against a fairly simple background- also keeps the focus on the image.








This is an add for eclipse gum I found in a Marie Claire magazine. (NOTE: The actual ad, itself, does not bleed to the edges of the page - originally there was about a 1/2 inch border all the way around but I had to do some cropping.)
In terms of hierarchy, I think this ad is easily entered. The product is a clear visual focal point. There is a genius use of white space in that the warm red accent behind both the text and product draw your eye to the areas indented for you to focus on. The starbursts are a bite cheesy but necessary. If the whole ad was red it would be difficult for your eye to focus because of the immense amount of color.
The block of text at the top is justified. This can be both good and bad. Lipton notes that justified alignment makes a clean figural shape on the page and is efficient use of space for continuous text - often used in newspapers or books(84). Since three lines of text are not exactly a continuous paragraph - justifying them can make these few words seem like a large block of text and therefore a little overwhelming. But because it is broken up with a variation in text size the main points are for the most part readable. The all-caps font choice makes a bold statement, but as we mentioned in class, it can sometime be difficult to read. In this ad I think it is, but because eclipse is seemingly going for a bold statement-type ad, it works. Overall: I thought this ad was a bite lackluster at first, but after looking at it further I can see where the designer was coming from.

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Movie poster as bad as movie itself


I think this Cloverfield field poster abused the kerning function. Although the imagery is nice, the letters are way too spaced out. I think it would look a lot better with a bigger font and therefore a smaller kerning. Although the movie was horrific, it had a lot of action and the font should be big and bold, not soft and spaced out. Plus, when you minimize the image, the text becomes unreadable, which is very bad when letting people know about the date and name of your movie.

Bad kerning/line spacing. Elena Carroll

The kerning in this picture just does not seem to work.  The lines don't even match up at the end, so the kerning on the top line is pointless.  It makes the sign hard to read, and my eye does not know where to look first.  The leading additionally makes it hard to read because the last two lines are so squished together.  I also don't understand why the first line is in bold to stand out, when it really does not contain any important part of the message.  

Kodak: Justification Issues



This is a Kodak advertisement from the 1980s. The headline and image are very captivating, and you would think that this would be an effective advertisement. However, the way everything is situated minimizes the effectiveness of the message. Because the headline isn't justified in any way, in order to be effective, the lines "A gift they can grow up with." should be in smaller type. The way it is now just looks sloppy. If they wanted to keep the same size of type, the creators of the advertisement could have at least adjusted the kerning, so the two lines matched up with each other. Not only do the lines look uneven and roughly put together, the product name ("A Kodak Camera") gets lost due to the similarity and again, unevenness, with the lines above. Though the body text is supposed to be a "text wrap," because of the extreme slant and large margins, at first glance, it looks as though it is flush right/ragged left justified. In addition, since the paragraphs are so small, there are a lot of awkward white spaces on the right, leading to hyphenated words and also to uneven right margins. In addition, according to the dates next to the Kodak logo (which I think should be a little bigger), this advertisement marked the 100th anniversary of the Kodak camera. Though this is a different topic, I believe they could have focused on that a little more in the ad. 100 years is a big deal, and means that Kodak is a trusted and effective brand. However, how could the cute kids not attract attention??

hierarchy used badly-- Julia Davis


This image uses type in a way that gives you no one place to "start" viewing the ad. Having the text in all caps makes for a fine headline, but the logo in all caps makes the ad overpowering and confusing. Although the headline should be the first place for the viewer to look, the logo should be the last thing the viewer remembers and recalls. Having no differentiation in size, color, or alignment makes this ad easy to overlook. Because all the type is equal the reader could possibly not know where to look, therefore skipping the ad altogether. To solve this problem the logo should make more of a statement and the heading could be in a different color or size to pull the reader into the ad and direct them where to go.

Daily Orange Ad: Michael Boren

The hierarchy on this ad on the Daily Orange's Web site is quite confusing. There's no real clear place to start, as different styles of type pop up all over the page. The DO tries to emphasize 'story,' 'event,' and 'DAILY' with a combination of bold and caps type styles. Parts of the page are also in lowercase letters though, which creates no consistency of type styles on the page. Not only does the reader not know where to enter or exit, but the use of different types of emphasis (bold, caps) is such a cluttered mess, it probably drives viewers away. Perhaps the DO should stick with one type of emphasis instead of bolding, not bolding, capitalizing and lowercasing words all over the ad.